Edinburgh Reviews

Local reviews of places, sights and attractions

  • Businesses
  • Entertainment
  • Festival
  • Food
  • Shopping
  • Travel
  • Et Al
You are here: Home / Entertainment / Review: The Curse of Monte Cristo

Review: The Curse of Monte Cristo

July 25, 2025 by Andrew Girdwood Leave a Comment

How do you breathe new life into one of literature’s most enduring tales of vengeance? You could do a lot worse than adding demons.

The Curse of Monte Cristo

The Curse of Monte Cristo isn’t just another adaptation of the classic novel. It’s a full-blown reinterpretation, taking Alexandre Dumas’s story and setting it smack in the middle of the Haitian Revolution. It then stirs in a healthy dose of supernatural horror that feels both audacious and, strangely, a perfect fit.

A Quick Confession

Right, let’s get this out of the way. Before picking this graphic novel up, I’d never actually read the original. I know, I know. I’ve since caught up and can confirm that Dumas’s The Count of Monte Cristo is surprisingly low on demonic pacts.

But the original does hint at forces beyond our world guiding the hero’s hand. So, for me, this version isn’t sacrilege; it’s just a fascinating path not taken. I came to it with no baggage, and I imagine some purists will be appalled. Their loss.

The Guts of the Story

Writers David Dabel and E.N. Holder make one huge, critical change inspired by their (and Dumas’s) shared Haitian heritage: Edmond Dantès is a Black man. When he’s framed by his racist, white rivals and thrown into the hellish Château d’If, his all-consuming need for revenge summons a demonic entity named Faria. In exchange for his soul, Faria offers him the power to escape and utterly ruin his enemies.

This reframing gives the quest for vengeance a profound new weight. It’s no longer just a personal vendetta; it’s a deeply cathartic struggle against the colonial powers that oppressed him. The pace is a whirlwind, sweeping you along in a torrent of blood, rebellion, and retribution. It cleverly keeps the key plot points of the original, so fans will still find it familiar, but the supernatural twist gives it a compelling dark-fantasy edge.

The Look and Feel

Visually, this book is a triumph. The artwork by David Lentz and Rodrigo Catraca is harsh, visceral, and full of sharp angles that keep you on edge. There’s a dramatic use of shadow and glowing colour that builds a gothic atmosphere, perfectly capturing the story’s blend of historical grit and demonic magic.

This isn’t a tale of cheap jump scares or gratuitous gore. It’s a more refined, unsettling kind of horror that gets under your skin.

Pages from graphic novel

The Verdict

Bold, thematically rich, and visually stunning, The Curse of Monte Cristo is a storming success. It proves that some stories aren’t just timeless, but can be reborn to speak powerfully to our own time.

It’s a must-read for lovers of graphic novels, dark fantasy, and classic literature. A highly recommended, and hugely enjoyable, deviation from the original.

Disclaimer: My copy of The Curse of Monte Cristo was provided free to review. The graphic novel is published by Andrews McMeel Publishing and distributed by Simon & Schuster.

The Curse of Monte Cristo

Andrew Girdwood

The Curse of Monte Cristo is a graphic novel reimagination of Alexandre Dumas’s classic The Count of Monte Cristo. It’s written by David Dabel and Carlton Holder, illustrated by David Lentz and Rodrigo Catraca.
Story
Art
Lettering

Summary

Dive into the haunting origins of the Haitian Revolution in this graphic novel, The Curse of Monte Cristo. Experience a gripping tale of revenge and reclamation, reimagined with a chilling horror twist.

4.3
The Curse of Monte Cristo

Share this:

  • Email a link to a friend (Opens in new window) Email
  • Share on Facebook (Opens in new window) Facebook
  • Share on X (Opens in new window) X

Related

Good news! We have a Redbubble store. It's home of our 'not an influencer' t-shirt.

Filed Under: Entertainment Tagged With: books, comics, graphic novels

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

About Us

  • » We're not influencers,
  • » We're boots on the ground,
  • » We're opinionated,
  • » ... and we're friendly.
  • » You can sponsor the blog/socials.

Features

  • Solo eating in Edinburgh
  • Edinburgh Gift Vouchers
  • Edinburgh Christmas
  • Edinburgh Festival
  • Edinburgh Authors
  • Edinburgh Broadband
  • How to submit a review
  • Contact Us

Recent Reviews

  • A Celestial Carnival: Basement Jaxx ignite the Usher Hall
  • Interview: Daliso Chaponda brings satire and ‘soft facts’ to Monkey Barrel
  • Review: Pronto Pizza, a pizza takeaway in Portobello
  • Review: Paesano Pizza, a city centre pizzeria
  • Review of Novapizza, a vegetarian restaurant in the New Town
  • Review: Eden’s Kitchen, a bistro on Broughton Street
  • Review: Civerinos, a Stockbridge pizzeria

About us

  • » Contact
  • » PR, media & us

Ads & Deals

  • » Sponsorship Deals

Copyright © 2026 — Edinburgh Reviews • All rights reserved.