Review: Fake, Fringe 2025

Chris Cook’s “Fake” is not just a magic show; it’s a history lesson, a philosophical debate, and a masterclass in storytelling. Housed in the Voodoo Rooms as part of the PBH’s Free Fringe, this show challenges the notion that “you get what you pay for.”

With a masterful performance, Cook draws the audience into the captivating true story of Han van Meegeren, the infamous Dutch forger who fooled the art world. This is a journey that is both educational and deeply personal, weaving the threads of art, deception, and truth into a compelling narrative.

The Art of Deception

The central thread of the show is the fascinating story of Han van Meegeren, a failed painter who, in a quest for recognition, decided to prove his talent by forging a masterpiece in the style of Johannes Vermeer. What follows is a tale of ambition and deceit, as van Meegeren’s forged paintings fooled experts and made him a fortune. Cook’s storytelling is masterful, holding the audience’s attention as the story unfolds. He wisely avoids giving away too many details, preserving the magic and mystery of van Meegeren’s confession. The narrative is so compelling that it’s easy to forget you’re watching a magic show. Cook’s assertion that van Meegeren may have been the more talented artist, and Vermeer the real “fake,” is a provocative and intriguing idea that plants a seed of doubt in the audience’s mind.

The Magic of the Mind

While the story is the star, the magic tricks are the clever vehicle that drives it forward. Cook’s sleight of hand is subtle and serves the narrative rather than dominating it. Some might initially roll their eyes at a classic card trick, but as Cook reveals how it’s done, you realise that these are not the real tricks. These are merely the setup for what’s truly impressive. His later illusions are baffling, leaving you genuinely trying to work out how they were performed. As the show progresses, Cook seamlessly connects the art of forgery with the art of illusion, asking profound questions about what is real and what is fake. In a world where AI and algorithms can alter a photograph, the show makes a timely observation: what is truth, and what is a lie? I agree with Chris. After all, we know the phrase “The camera never lies,” but in the age of digital manipulation, are photographs still the truth?

Overall

“Fake” is a triple threat: an entertaining magic show, a compelling story, and a local act from an Edinburgh-based performer. Chris Cook has crafted a thought-provoking and clever performance that is both educational and thrilling. It’s a show that will make you reconsider what you believe to be true, and it’s a genuine treat of the Free Fringe. While you may have to queue to get in, it is absolutely worth the wait.