Review: Baker Street Ladies, Fringe 2025

In a city with a plethora of Sherlock Holmes-themed plays, finding one that stands out can be a challenge.

Baker Street Ladies is a one-woman show that rises to that challenge by turning the spotlight away from the famous detective and onto the women who knew him best. Set in the iconic 221B Baker Street, the play gives a voice to Mrs. Hudson, Mary Watson, and Irene Adler. Through a series of monologues, they share their unique perspectives on the world of Sherlock Holmes, revealing unseen sides of Victorian London and the lives of those who orbited the brilliant but often difficult man.

A Test of Acting Prowess

The central, and most impressive, aspect of this production is the performance of Lexi Wolfe. In a captivating display of theatrical skill, Wolfe transforms herself into three distinct women with a simple and very quick change of costume. Each character feels fully realised, from the long-suffering and surprisingly resilient Mrs. Hudson to the wistful Mary Watson, who finds herself as the ‘third wheel’ in the Holmes and Watson relationship.

While all three performances are strong, the portrayal of Mrs. Hudson is a particular highlight. Her dry wit and quiet strength are wonderfully captured, making her the audience’s favourite. It is a true testament to Wolfe’s acting that she can take a character often relegated to the background and make her so compelling. The seamless transition between roles keeps the audience engaged, demonstrating the kind of talent that can hold the attention of a relatively full house, including some youngsters (who did not become fidgeters). “She was my favourite” and “she kept it all together” are the sorts of comments that are well deserved.

However, the whole play therefore bet heavily on how much I related to any of the three women, and only Mrs Hudson stood out to me.

The Audience as a Participant

The play’s structure, while consisting mainly of monologues, subtly involves the audience. We are addressed directly at times, almost as if we are a silent confidant or a new arrival to Baker Street. This simple device creates an intimate atmosphere, drawing us into the stories being told. The monologues serve as reflections, giving the women a chance to air their grievances and share their secrets.

For fans of the original Conan Doyle stories, this show provides a fresh and compelling new angle. It’s an interesting premise that works well, offering a unique perspective that is rarely explored. “The only Sherlock Holmes adaptation I’ve seen told exclusively through the eyes of the female characters” is a great way to put it, and makes this a must-see for anyone who has ever wondered about the lives of the women behind the great man.

Overall

Baker Street Ladies is an intriguing and well-executed production. While it may not be the most bombastic Sherlock Holmes adaptation you’ll ever see, it offers a thoughtful and unique alternative. The show’s strength lies in its captivating central performance and its novel approach to a classic tale. If you are a fan of Conan Doyle, and particularly if you’re interested in the untold stories of his female characters, this is definitely one to consider and well worth an hour of your time.